Rep. James Walkinshaw speaks to congressional interns in July 2026 (adapted from photo from the Office of Rep. James Walkinshaw)

Democrats on the House Oversight Committee launched their first major salvo this week in the form of a dozen letters to Trump administration officials and allies notifying them of investigations to come in the new Congress. The letters covered a range of issues, including the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement abuses, which have drawn widespread condemnation within the party.
Democratic Congressman James Walkinshaw represents Virginia’s 11th District, and he has a unique position in the current Congress as the only Democrat who sits on both the House Oversight and the Homeland Security committees. He has strongly condemned the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement practices, and we spoke this week about how Democrats should approach immigration enforcement oversight in the next Congress and how they can rein in the administration.
“I think there’s close to unanimity among Democrats around the basic reforms that we were fighting for over the course of the last year,” Walkinshaw said, “the end to masking, the requirement for judicial warrants to enter homes and/or vehicles, use-of-force policies that are actually enforced with real discipline, improved training standards, [and] an end to racial profiling.”
“I think you’ll see us next year fighting to get some of that language into appropriations bills,” he said, but he cautioned that “because of the massive amounts of money that the Republican Congress gave to ICE and CBP through reconciliation, under any circumstances — any appropriation circumstance — they’re likely to continue functioning and operating.”
We also discussed the Trump administration’s “sad and pathetic” threat to criminally investigate Democrats in response to their oversight work.
“We accept that maybe we’ll face some kind of sham prosecution,” Walkinshaw said, “and we’ll fight it out as others have and ultimately prevail.”
Check out the transcript below or watch the whole thing on YouTube:
How House Democrats Plan to Investigate ICE
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
 
You and your colleagues sent a series of letters to the administration on a host of oversight issues, including immigration enforcement. There’s a very long list of ICE and immigration enforcement abuses — including the deaths at the hands of immigration officers, the administration’s third-country deportation policy, and conditions at detention facilities.
How do you even begin to wrap your arms around this issue as you think about the things you want to investigate in the majority?
On the Oversight Committee, we collected more than 1,000 allegations of use-of-force violations or abuses of power. And there have been many other allegations documented across the country.
Are we as a committee going to be able to go through and kind of adjudicate or attempt to discern precisely what happened in each altercation or incident? Obviously not.
I think what we will have to do is use the data we’ve collected and received from the American people about these incidents and try to group them and then identify the systemic decisions that allowed them to happen.
  “Even if it were a well-run local police department, you would have more than one officer disciplined for violating use-of-force policy”
The Homeland Security Committee met with the ICE leadership several months ago and asked about how many ICE officers have been disciplined over the course of the year.
The response was one officer had faced any kind of discipline. That’s a shocking number, given the number of ICE officers.
Even if it were a well-run local police department, you would have more than one officer disciplined for violating use-of-force policy. There’s clearly something systemic there.
When somebody like Stephen Miller and others in leadership in the administration assert that ICE officers have full legal immunity, that’s obviously something that’s false and systemic that needs to be reviewed and analyzed and ultimately reformed, from my perspective.
I think that will be our approach: take this huge amount of data and some of these horrifying stories and incidents and put them into buckets to try to identify the systemic causes.
My goal — and I think what our goal should be — is developing the reforms and the policy response to ensure that it stops happening and can’t happen again in the future.
You are the only Democrat who sits on both the House Oversight and the Homeland Security committees. What has that experience been like, and how has it shaped your perspective around these issues?
I think it’s been useful. It was not by design when I started, but it’s been coincidentally useful.
As the Oversight Committee has been collecting these stories of incidents across the country, I was meeting with ICE leadership as a member of the Homeland Security Committee and hearing from then-Secretary [Kristi] Noem and now Secretary [Markwayne] Mullin on their perspectives on what’s taking place.
It has been useful to be in both positions. I guess I just have a slightly broader perspective and view than someone who is only on one or the other committee might have had over the course of the last year.
You’re going to be in the majority in January, and funding for the federal government is going to be a big issue on a bunch of different dimensions.
I know this is a very difficult question with a lot of complicated implications, but what do you think should happen with funding for DHS and the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement efforts, and how far do you think your colleagues in the caucus are willing to go on this issue? Is this one of these issues that could precipitate a shutdown?
Well, it’s hard. The kind of shutdown predictions, especially with respect to next year, are difficult.
I think there’s close to unanimity among Democrats around the basic reforms that we were fighting for over the course of the last year — the end to masking, the requirement for judicial warrants to enter homes and/or vehicles, use-of-force policies that are actually enforced with real discipline, improved training standards, an end to racial profiling, which I think is clear has occurred and was at certain points countenanced by this administration.
I think Democrats are unanimous around that. I think you’ll see us next year fighting to get some of that language into appropriations bills.
Obviously, one of the challenges is, in terms of funding, because of the massive amounts of money that the Republican Congress gave to ICE and CBP through reconciliation, under any circumstances — any appropriation circumstance — they’re likely to continue functioning and operating.
So we’ll be fighting in other DHS arenas to try to get those reforms that would apply to ICE and CBP.
This is definitely not the fault of the administration’s political opposition, but one of the things we’ve seen over the last two years is this administration routinely violating budget laws and appropriations restrictions — moving money around, basically to do whatever they want.
How do you try to discipline or monitor that?
Well, there’s two things that are really critical. One is taking place as we speak, and that’s the administration’s effort to install and rush through — and, I think, illegally rush through — the installation of a new leader at the Government Accountability Office.
  “The individual that the Trump administration is trying to install would be, for the first time ever in GAO’s history, a partisan figure, a partisan operative at the head of what’s supposed to be an independent, nonpartisan organization”
I think it’s clear that the Government Accountability Office has standing to file suit against an administration that’s violating federal budget laws with the illegal impoundments and, in some cases, the rescissions.
The current interim director of GAO made a decision not to test that in court. I think the future leader of GAO needs to pursue that.
The individual that the Trump administration is trying to install would be, for the first time ever in GAO’s history, a partisan figure, a partisan operative at the head of what’s supposed to be an independent, nonpartisan organization.
I think that fight right now taking place in the Senate is really, really important.
Next year, Democrats are going to have to build on the work — and there was some bipartisan support for this, and still is — ensuring that appropriations bills are written in a way that makes it much harder for the Trump administration to ignore them.
Obviously, in a new Congress in January, we’ll have the opportunity to — as a Congress, as a House, or as a Senate — make the decision to go to court and fight for our constitutional power of the purse. I think we’re going to have to pursue all of those avenues.
Last but not least: The Justice Department threatened you and your colleagues with criminal investigations for conducting oversight of the administration. You sent out a statement describing those threats as “pathetic” — which they are, and they’re legally nonsensical.
On the other hand, as you know, it’s not entirely beyond the realm of possibility, because the administration is currently prosecuting your colleague Congresswoman LaMonica McIver.
What has the reaction been like within the caucus — you and your colleagues — knowing that the threats are frivolous, but also that this is an administration where you can’t entirely write them off?
  “I knew, running for this job, that there’s a possibility that anyone who opposes Donald Trump, especially a political figure of the other party, could face a political prosecution”
I made a decision to run for this job in the middle of 2025. That was a moment in time where the Trump administration was making threats and people were taking those threats very seriously. Law firms and universities and politicians were backing down in the face of those threats.
I knew, running for this job, that there’s a possibility that anyone who opposes Donald Trump, especially a political figure of the other party, could face a political prosecution. I made that decision going into it that I’m willing to take that risk.
I don’t discount at all the way that these kinds of politicized prosecutions can upend somebody’s life, especially a private citizen: the expense, the death threats that come as a result of it.
To see what has happened to my colleague LaMonica is just horrific.
With that said, I think the number of losses that this Justice Department has put up on the scoreboard in all of these cases makes their continued issuance of these threats, as I said in the statement, sad and pathetic.
It just doesn’t carry the same weight that it maybe would have with some in 2025, and we just can’t allow it to deter us.
As you know better than most, our constitutional authority to conduct oversight is absolutely rock-solid and ironclad. And I’m confident that the courts would agree with that.
For me and my colleagues on the Oversight Committee: We accept that maybe we’ll face some kind of sham prosecution, and we’ll fight it out as others have and ultimately prevail.
 
Open File is on video and across social media. Follow wherever you read or watch.
YouTube
Instagram
 
TikTok
X
 
Bluesky
Threads
 
If you like what you just read, please spread the word.
Bluesky · X · Threads · LinkedIn · Reddit · Email
 
Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe
Add Open File as a preferred source on Google