Illustration by Open File (adapted from images of the International Criminal Court and Marco Rubio)

On Friday, Secretary of State Marco Rubio delivered a speech to the Federalist Society that featured some of his trademark flourishes — pseudo-intellectual references to ancient history, terrible writing, and over-the-top attacks on the International Criminal Court.
Rubio described the ICC as “a fake court” and “an unelected world tribunal, which claims to supersede the laws and constitutions of sovereign states, even those who never signed up for it.” He added that “if they’re foolish enough to try to enforce their paper decrees on Americans, our answer will probably be the same as the Roman general Pompey, when he said to those who were trying to invoke their cities’ charters against his legions: ‘Stop quoting laws to men with swords.’” Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth echoed those words over the weekend.
As silly as all of this pseudo-masculine posturing sounds, the statements by Rubio and Hegseth are notable. They represent a significant but relatively recent shift in the Trump administration’s approach and rhetoric toward the ICC — and they make clear that the administration’s real concern at this point is that the ICC will prosecute top Trump officials like Rubio and Hegseth after they leave the White House.
For most of Trump’s second term, the standard line from the administration and its supporters was that the ICC needed to be reined in for two reasons — first, because the ICC issued arrest warrants for Israeli leaders in connection with the war in the Middle East, and second, because the ICC’s investigation into the war in Afghanistan included within its scope the conduct of US military personnel.
Neither of those rationales provides a credible basis for the administration’s position anymore. Support for the Israeli government among the US public has collapsed, and last week, judges at the ICC effectively ended the inquiry into the conduct of US service members in Afghanistan.
As the facts have changed, the administration has become clearer about its real concerns.
In June, Rubio wrote an op-ed for the Wall Street Journal that asked us to “imagine a world in which U.S. soldiers, police officers, Border Patrol agents and elected leaders could be dragged before an international court.” When Rubio announced the imposition of heavy sanctions on the court in October, he likewise invoked the prospect of the ICC prosecuting “elected leaders ensuring our national security.”
That has always been where the risk of an ICC prosecution — such as it is — actually lies. For instance, I did a piece about this last year focused on the administration’s military campaign targeting alleged drug boats in international waters near Central and South America. There are also questions about whether top Trump administration officials could — at least in theory — be prosecuted over the capture of Nicolás Maduro in Venezuela and the decision to go to war with Iran. Despite the administration’s claims, no credible observer seriously believes that the ICC would prosecute the service members involved ahead of the US political leaders who directed their conduct.
The administration’s real motivation for attacking the ICC — fear of being prosecuted by the court in the future — is not a trivial question given the ongoing legal and diplomatic disputes concerning the US sanctions regime directed at the court and the people around it.
Last month, a federal judge in Manhattan ruled that the administration could not impose an earlier round of sanctions against two nonprofits that provide support for the ICC’s work because the sanctions likely violate the First Amendment. The same judge is presiding over other challenges to US sanctions that have been filed by several ICC judges and a consortium of US nonprofits.
The most potent sanctions, however, are those that were threatened against the court itself by Rubio in October.
Technically, that order came with a six-month grace period to allow US companies — like tech service providers and banks — to wind down any business relationships with the court. The administration’s objective, if the sanctions go into effect, is to make the court literally incapable of operating (as Rubio likes to say, to “dismantle the ICC — brick-by-brick, if necessary”).
It is telling that Rubio delivered his speech on Friday to the Federalist Society. Rubio probably believes that the administration’s continued broadside against the ICC — even if it is entirely self-interested and corruptly motivated — can garner the support of the conservative legal establishment, and he may be right about that.
Conservatives often argue, as Rubio did on Friday, that the court is illegitimate because it claims jurisdiction over Americans abroad, but that argument is specious. Generally speaking, the ICC’s assertion of jurisdiction is based on whether the conduct at issue occurred on the territory of a country (like Afghanistan) that signed or ratified the treaty that created the ICC. In other words, the court’s jurisdiction is based on the combined legal and territorial sovereignty of the signatories. (The UN Security Council can also make referrals to the ICC, but the US can veto those referrals.)
The countries that are parties to the ICC are also free to prosecute US personnel under their own laws — the same way we prosecute people from foreign countries under our laws and in our courts if they commit crimes on our land — but the ICC is often called a “court of last resort” for a reason. That is because those countries’ governments may be at war with the perpetrators or otherwise incapable of investigating the conduct at issue without the support and resources of the ICC.
It remains to be seen whether and to what extent the Trump administration’s effort to dismantle the ICC through its sanctions regime will prove successful.
One thing, however, should be clear: The US should not be abusing its economic and political power to destroy a multilateral international institution that we don’t like — particularly since the only reason at this point appears to be fear among top Trump administration officials that they have violated so many international laws so egregiously that they could be prosecuted in the future. The American people did not sign up for this, and the Republicans’ recent midterm wipeout has eviscerated any claim to public support for the Trump administration’s antics on the world stage.
All that said, the prospect of the ICC prosecuting top US officials would be highly controversial among Americans, to say the least. The US government, under administrations spanning both parties, has refused to recognize the ICC’s jurisdiction over Americans.
In fact, there is probably only one scenario in which Trump’s political opposition and the American people might ever seriously entertain it — and that is if Trump issues a mass pardon before leaving office in order to prevent the next administration from enforcing US criminal laws against his top officials.
Under that unprecedented scenario, the political and legal basis for an internationally led investigation and prosecution looks a lot different. After all, the ICC is called a “court of last resort” for a reason.
 
The Docket
•Democrats to Lean on Bolder Whistleblowers to Probe Trump’s DOJ (Bloomberg)
•Democrats Call for Probe Into Military Leaders as U.S. Army Whistleblower Alleges Warnings Were Dismissed Ahead of Deadly Iran Attack (TIME)
•Trump’s judge appointment blitz faces Republican resistance (Reuters)
•Trump’s border crackdown faces a new blue wall of governors and House members (Axios)
•US DOJ warns Senator Warren about potential Trump-related probes (Reuters)
•Blanche says ‘incoming freshmen’ Democrats calling to probe Trump are ‘acting like prosecutors’ (The Hill)
 
Open File is on video and across social media. Follow wherever you read or watch.
YouTube
Instagram
 
TikTok
X
 
Bluesky
Threads
 
If you like what you just read, please spread the word.
Bluesky · X · Threads · LinkedIn · Reddit · Email
 
Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe
Add Open File as a preferred source on Google