| The Justice Department’s public and political standing is at a low point, despite the posturing of top administration officials. Public approval of the department’s work is underwater, and the department just wrapped up an unprecedented campaign to interfere in the midterm elections for partisan purposes. |
| You would not know that from the tone of the remarks that have come from Todd Blanche and other top lawyers in the Trump administration. Blanche spent the week trying to defend his threats to criminally investigate Democratic lawmakers engaged in oversight of the administration. On Wednesday, White House counsel Will Scharf sent Democratic Rep. Robert Garcia a letter claiming that his oversight efforts could veer into “blatant criminality.” One of the US attorneys in Texas threatened Democratic Sen. Richard Blumenthal with a criminal investigation as well. |
| These are preposterous claims, and although they are intended to project strength, they convey the opposite. |
| As a legal matter, the threats are frivolous. No credible lawyer believes that congressional oversight — even angry and wildly partisan congressional oversight — is a crime. |
| As a political and practical matter, the threats are pointless. They are not credible or persuasive, and they will not deter any of the upcoming oversight work because congressional Democrats are not complete morons. The administration is likely to stonewall those oversight efforts, but no one is seriously worried about criminal exposure. |
| Meanwhile, the department has seen a flurry of political appointees leave in the wake of the midterms. The head of the Civil Rights Division left, reportedly over Trump’s unhappiness with a television interview. Blanche pushed out the head of the National Security Division, reportedly after a dispute about media leak investigations. One of the US attorneys in Florida left after overseeing the “grand conspiracy” investigation, an exercise in futility that is going nowhere fast. The head of the Civil Division is gone too, but it does not appear to have anything to do with his dismal performance. |
| Taken together, these developments suggest that the Trump DOJ will stay the course despite the midterm results, and that the country should prepare for more partisan abuses of power in Trump’s remaining years — even as the department’s ability to follow through on these threats is diminishing by the day. |
| Judges and grand juries have pushed back on Trump’s efforts to use the Justice Department to punish his political adversaries, and if anything, we should expect to see more of that. The department’s senior ranks are severely diminished after an exodus of career officials, which has meant that political appointees have been handling more cases in the courts and losing them in spectacular fashion. The loss of rank-and-file DOJ lawyers has also hobbled the department’s ability to defend the government effectively in civil litigation and handle appeals. |
| Things could get worse at the department before they get better, but the week’s events served as a reminder that the DOJ is in historic disarray under this administration — and that it is vital to start planning for a post-Trump DOJ sooner rather than later. |
| The list of problems is too long to detail here, but Blanche and his predecessor, former Attorney General Pam Bondi, have done remarkable long-term damage to the department — gutting key offices and enforcement programs, shifting law enforcement efforts heavily toward immigration crimes and away from pretty much everything else, and allowing Trump to use the department to pursue political vendettas and grievances. |
| There are several reasons for this work to get underway — not least because it will be complex and time-consuming. Just as important, Blanche and the remaining political appointees should remember that there will be another administration soon enough — and that they should not assume that that administration will bungle the post-Trump reform and accountability process like the last one did. |
| If we learned anything from last week’s election results, it’s that Americans are fed up with this administration, its failures, and its abuses. Blanche, Scharf, and other administration officials can posture and send all of the threatening letters in the world, but the act was never persuasive to begin with — and, at this point, it’s a sign of weakness and desperation, not strength. |